Wednesday, July 05, 2006

This is a Pulitzer Prize winning photo taken in 1994 during the Sudan famine. The picture depicts a famine-stricken girl crawling toward a United Nations food camp, located one kilometre away.

The vulture is waiting for the child to die so it can eat her. Nobody knows what happened to the child including photographer Kevin Carter, who took the picture and left the area immediately.

Kevin Carter committed suicide 3 months later.

_____________________

Carter, a white South African, spent only a couple of days in Sudan. According to Susan D Moeller, who tells Carter's story in Compassion Fatigue: How the Media Sell Disease, Famine, War and Death, he had gone into the bush seeking relief from the terrible starvation and suffering he was documenting, when he encountered the emaciated girl. When he saw the vulture land, Carter waited quietly, hoping the bird would spread its wings and give him an even more dramatic image. It didn't, and he eventually chased the bird away. The girl gathered her strength and resumed her journey toward a feeding centre. Afterward, writes Moeller, Carter "sat by a tree, talked to God, cried, and thought about his own daughter, Megan."

When the image of the prostrate girl and the patient vulture appeared, many people demanded to know what had happened to her. The New York Times explained in an editors' note that while she resumed her trek, the photographer didn't know if she had survived. Carter stood accused; callers in the middle of the night denounced him. The girl began to haunt the photographer. In June 1994, Carter, beset by difficulties, killed himself. His suicide note speaks of the ghosts he could not escape, the "vivid memories of killings & corpses; anger & pain," and the "starving and wounded children" ever before his eyes.

In Carter's case, Western newspaper readers saw a little girl. Carter, in the Sudanese village where he landed, was watching 20 people starve to death each hour. Perhaps he might have laid aside his camera to give the victims what succor he could (and thus never have encountered the girl in the bush); perhaps his photographs could have led to greater help than he could personally give. Should he have carried one girl to safety? Carter was surrounded by hundreds of starving children. When he sat by the tree and wept, it was beneath a burden of futility. But his was not a photo of futility, nor of mass starvation, nor of religious factionalism, nor of civil war. Readers saw only a little girl.

Taken from: http://flatrock.org.nz/topics/odds_and_oddities/ultimate_in_unfair.htm

4 Comments:

Blogger Deborah said...

He did chase away the vulture, but no - he did not assist the child.

Wed Jul 05, 08:44:00 PM  
Blogger john said...

what a touching photo and story . that vulture is an ' animal ' .

Thu Jul 06, 05:15:00 PM  
Blogger coach said...

What a depressing sight . I hope such will not be repeated anywhere .

Thu Jul 06, 07:50:00 PM  
Blogger Deborah said...

None of us here can possibly know what futility he felt, or how one manages to maintain perspective when faced with such volatile subject matter as a photojournalist. I know what I hope I would do... but as you say: we weren't there.

Sat Jul 08, 08:50:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home